Newspapers Report Decline of Reviews in Newspapers
Posted by: Keir Graff
To some authors and critics, these moves amount to yet one more nail in the coffin of literary culture. But some publishers and literary bloggers – not surprisingly – see it as an inevitable transition toward a new, more democratic literary landscape where anyone can comment on books. In recent years, dozens of sites, including Bookslut.com, The Elegant Variation (marksarvas.blogs.com/elegvar/), maudnewton .com, Beatrice.com and the Syntax of Things (syntaxofthings.typepad.com), have been offering a mix of book news, debates, interviews and reviews, often on subjects not generally covered by newspaper book sections.
For those who are used to the old way, it’s a tough evolution. "Like anything new, it’s difficult for authors and agents to understand when we say, ‘I’m sorry, you’re not going to be in The New York Times or The Chicago Tribune, but you are going to be at curledup.com,’ " said Trish Todd, publisher of Touchstone Fireside, an imprint of Simon & Schuster. "But we think that’s the wave of the future."
Maud Newton offers a balanced assessment…
"I find it kind of naïve and misguided to be a triumphalist blogger," Ms. Newton said. "But I also find it kind of silly when people in the print media bash blogs as a general category, because I think the people are doing very, very different things."
…while Richard Ford reviews the medium without having read it:
Of course literary bloggers argue that they do provide a multiplicity of voices. But some authors distrust those voices. Mr. Ford, who has never looked at a literary blog, said he wanted the judgment and filter that he believed a newspaper book editor could provide. "Newspapers, by having institutional backing, have a responsible relationship not only to their publisher but to their readership," Mr. Ford said, "in a way that some guy sitting in his basement in Terre Haute maybe doesn’t."
And what’s so bad about basements? Plenty of novels have been written in basements, and we don’t give those authors crap about it. Good writing is good writing. Bad writing is bad writing. Some of it is on blogs, some of it is in newspapers.
We’re talking about this in the Booklist Book Club, too.